West Village Pizza Menu

SLICES & PIES

SLICE | PIE
  • classic plain 3.50 | 24

    crushed tomato sauce + mozzarella

  • pepperoni 4.50 | 28

    pecorino romano, mozzarella, + pepperoni

  • street fair 5.25 | 34

    sausage, shaved sweet onion, + chopped cherry peppers

  • new margherita 5.25 | 34

    sauce, pecorino romano, post oven stracciatella, basil, + extra virgin olive oil

  • vodka pie 4.75 | 32

    vodka sauce, pecorino romano, 
fresh mozzarella

  • sausage 4.50 | 28

    with hand pinched sweet fennel sausage

  • mushroom 4.50 | 28

    with seasoned fresh cremini mushrooms

  • yo paulie 5.25 | 34

    pepperoni, honey drizzle, + chopped cherry peppers

  • white pie 5.25 | 34

    mozzarella, fresh ricotta, pecorino romano, chopped garlic, + extra virgin olive oil

EXTRA TOPPINGS

$1 per slice | $4 per pie

pepperoni
mushroom
olive

sausage
jalapeno
onion

$1.50 per slice | $5 per pie

spicy pepperoni
stracciatella
eggplant

Pizza West Village​

SQUARES

SLICE | PIE
  • spicy pepperoni 4.50 | 28

    crushed red pepper, fresh mozzarella, + thick hand cut, spicy pepperoni

  • original grandma 4.50 | 28

    fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, hand-crushed seasoned plum tomatoes, fresh chopped garlic, sicilian oregano, extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil

  • pepperoni grandma 5.00 | 32

    pecorino romano, mozzarella, + pepperoni

  • eggplant 5.00 | 32

    fresh mozzarella, sicilian oregano, parmigiano cheese, + fresh eggplant

  • drunken grandma 5.00 | 32

    fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, vodka sauce, sicilian oregano, extra virgin olive oil, + fresh basil

  • white grandma 5.00 | 32

    fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, fresh chopped garlic, sicilian oregano, extra virgin olive oil, + fresh basil

  • upside down 4.75 | 30

    fresh mozzarella, parmigiano cheese, sicilian oregano, + extra virgin olive oil

West Village Pizza

VEGAN & GLUTEN FREE

SLICE | PIE
  • vegan cheese 28

    sauce + violife vegan mozzarella

  • gluten-free personal pie 18+

    any round pie 18 + $2 per topping

  • vegan grandma 5.00 | 32

    violife vegan mozzarella, hand-crushed seasoned plum tomatoes, fresh chopped garlic, sicilian oregano, extra virgin olive oil, + fresh basil

SALADS & BREAD

  • garlic Knots 4.00
  • chopped spicy italian salad 9.00

    any round pie 18 + $2 per topping

  • caesar Salad 8.00

BEVERAGES

  • bottles 3.50

    mexican coke, mexican sprite, mexican orange fanta

  • cans 2.50

    coca-cola, diet coke, sprite, grape soda, root beer, ginger ale, & seltzer

  • bottled water 2.50

* New York State Sales Tax Not Included.

Payment with credit or debit card will incur a non-cash adjustment fee of 3.95%. There is no fee applied for cash payments.

NYC Pizza

West Village

Best Pizza West Village

Made in New York Pizza Menu

Look no further than our West Village pizza place if you want the very best that the city has to offer! Our menu has a vast array of different topping and flavor options, so you’ll definitely find a slice or more that will exceed your expectations here at Made in New York Pizza.

Our West Village Location

NYC Wall Art

One aspect of this location that stands out from the rest of the pizzerias in the West Village is the wall art. Not only are the designs really fun to look at, but they also contain non-fungible tokens (NFTs) that make them one of a kind works of art that you can’t experience anywhere else.

In case you didn’t know, NFTs are a combination of art and technology that contain blockchains from a cryptocurrency that contain information showing that it’s the original work and not a replica or reprint. Come to our pizza place and see them for yourself!

Dine In or Order Online

There are two different ways that you can order our food: either by dining in at our location that’s a couple of blocks from Hudson River Park or ordering online to get it delivered to your home or hotel room if you’re not local to the city. No matter how you order, you know that your pizza craving for a slice or a few will be surely satisfied.