New York Style Pizza Shops Near the West Side Highway & Pier 45

If you’re in the mood for the best authentic New York pizza, we have some good news. Made In New York Pizza’s four locations ensure that there’s always a great pizza shop near you. Whenever you have the urge for pizza, we’re close at hand and ready to take your order. We even offer delivery!

Our delicious award-winning pizzas are a slice above the rest. We’ve worked hard to bring you everything that is truly great about pizza in New York. From our fresh, high-quality ingredients to our authentic brick pizza oven, everything on our menu is made with the care and attention your taste buds deserve.

Whether you’re looking for a Neapolitan New York-style pie or a Sicilian square pizza, our menu has you covered. If you’ve never tried a Grandma pizza, you’re in for a nostalgic Italian-American treat. Whatever you choose to order, slice or pie, our delicious topping combinations create a taste sensation you just can’t get anywhere else.

Made In New York Pizza is more than just your local pizza shop. Wherever we go, we become a staple of the community, a go-to pizza shop for locals, visitors, and even the occasional celebrity. We want everyone to feel welcome and have a top-notch pizza experience every time they visit us.

Perfect Pizza Techniques

What makes the best local pizza shop? When it comes down to it, it’s all about the pizza – and making a great slice starts with the perfect pizza technique. 

A thin crust is essential to a great New York-style pizza. Our pizza chefs are experts in stretching and shaping our dough to create a thin and crispy crust on all our New York-style pies. This is always done by hand to keep the moisture in the dough and prevent a dry crust. The pizza dough toss creates air pockets in the dough, giving it a lighter texture once baked. It also helps to shape it into a pizza-perfect circle.

New York-style pizzas are often topped with pepperoni, mushrooms, and onions. We’ve included all of these traditional flavors in our pizza shop menu, as well as some innovative twists. (Seriously, don’t sleep on the homemade vodka sauce!). We’re known for being generous with all of our toppings. We like to ensure that every bite is a taste of pizza perfection!

The brick oven is an essential part of achieving this goal. Brick ovens are designed to distribute their heat evenly, ensuring that every mouthful is just right. They also add a unique depth of flavor to the crust as it bakes, making each pizza mind-blowingly delicious.

No matter which pie you choose, you’ll be able to taste our top-quality ingredients and attention to detail in every part of the pizza-making process.

Signature Pizza Selections

Does your closest pizza shop offer you a pizza for every mood? We sure do! 

Looking for that classic comfort pizza? Our menu features pizza shop icons like classic cheese, pepperoni, and Margherita pizzas, all made with the freshest ingredients in top-tier New York style. Want a little something more? Take it up a notch with a specialty pie – our BBQ chicken pizza is always a winner – or try one of our many vegetarian options. 

Or why not try our mouth-watering range of Sicilian pizzas? These rectangular pizzas have a thicker crust and hint of pecorino that sets them apart from the familiar New York-style pie. Sicilian pizza also usually puts the sauce on top of the cheese, preventing it from being overcooked. If you prefer your cheese on top, you can get the best of both worlds with a slice or two of our Upside Down Sicilian.

We honor the best traditions of generations of Italian-American nonnas with our grandma pizza, giving it our own modern twist, of course. Although it’s rectangular, like the Sicilian, the grandma pizza has a thinner crust and is baked in a sheet pan. Try our Original Grandma, topped with pepperoni, basil, and extra-virgin olive oil, or maybe shake things up with a Drunken Grandma drizzled with our homemade vodka sauce.

Beyond Pizza: Salads & Sides

A great local pizza shop pays attention to every detail of the meal. At Made In New York Pizza, the salads and side dishes that make the meal complete aren’t an afterthought. We pride ourselves on ensuring that every dish that comes out of our kitchen reflects our commitment to giving you the best meal experience.

Whether as a complement to your pizza slice or the main event, our salads are dressed to impress. Each one is made with fresh ingredients, delivering crisp flavor and just the right amount of crunch. Why not pair one with some fresh, hot garlic knots and a side of marinara? Take a look at your local menu for a full list of our sides.

Round out your pizza shop visit with a refreshing drink; our fridges are always stocked with a variety of sodas and bottled water. Apart from being a classic combination, carbonated drinks also help balance the rich, cheesy pizza flavors. Ask your waiter which soda they recommend to complement your next order!

Be a Part of Our Pizza Shop Community

Made In New York Pizza is much more than a pizza shop near you. We don’t just want to make pizza; we want to make great pizza. Whether you choose a slice or pie, round or square, our mission is to deliver the best of New York pizza.

With each of our locations, we have expanded our reach to more neighborhoods in Manhattan so more people can enjoy our top-quality pizza. Pizza is our passion, and we want to share it with New York locals and visitors alike. Our pizza shops are a testament to our commitment to creating good food, great flavors, and a welcoming environment. So, pull up a chair and join us for a slice at a Made In New York Pizza location near you!