YOU GET A SQUARE, YOU GET A SLICE – EVERYONE GETS A PIE!

In 2018, a pizza allegiance was born. Indeed, saucy reports confirmed that this Upper West Side pizza place made an oven-baked oath to firmly uphold the soft, thick, and crispy code of crust – one that effortlessly folds into every hand that has touched it since.

Folks came for the pizza cravings but stayed for what turned out to be an irresistible assortment of slices, whole pies, and squares. As we speak, the Made in New York allegiance has grown with several locations across the city.

SLICES & PIES

SLICE / PIE
  • PLAIN CHEESE 3.75 | 25

    Tomatoes, Mozzarella, Pecorino, Oregano

  • MUSHROOM 4.75 | 30

    Tomatoes, Mozzarella, Pecorino, Oregano, and Fresh Mushrooms

  • PEPPERONI 4.75 | 30

    California Tomatoes, Mozzarella, Pecorino, Oregano, Pepperoni

  • MARGHERITA 4.75 | 30

    Plum Tomato Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Pecorino, Fresh Garlic, Basil and E.V.O.O

  • NEW MARGHERITA 5.25 | 32

    Tomatoes, Pecorino, Post-oven Stracciatella, Basil, and E.V.O.O

  • VODKA 4.75 | 30

    Vodka Sauce, Pecorino, Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, and E.V.O.O

  • WHITE SPINACH 5.50 | 35

    A Blend of Cheeses, Fresh Garlic, Spinach, Ricotta

  • BBQ CHICKEN 5.50 | 35

    Mozzarella Cheese, Breaded Chicken Marinated In Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ Sauce

  • BUFFALO CHICKEN 5.50 | 35

    Mozzarella Cheese, Breaded Chicken Marinated In Frank’s Red Hot Sauce, and Ranch Drizzle

  • SAUSAGE JALAPEÑO 5.50 | 35
  • PEPPERONI SAUSAGE 5.50 | 35
  • Yo Paulie 5.25 | 32
  • Street Fair 5.25 | 32

    Tomatoes, Mozzarella, Pecorino, Oregano, Sweet Italian Sausage, White Onion, and Hot Cherry Peppers

VEGAN & GLUTEN FREE
SLICE / PIE
  • GLUTEN-FREE PERSONAL PIE
    Any Round Pie 18 + $2 per Topping
    18+
all prices are in $
SQUARES
SLICE / PIE
  • GRANDMA 4.75 | 30
  • UPSIDE DOWN 4.75 | 30
  • CLASSIC SICILIAN 4.75 | 30
  • VEGGIE 5.50 | 35
  • WHITE 5.50 | 35
  • EGGPLANT 5.50 | 35
  • SPICY PEPPERONI 5.50 | 35
EXTRA TOPPINGS
5 PER TOPPING
ADDITIONAL TOPPINGS
  • MUSHROOM
  • OLIVE
  • ONION
  • PEPPERONI
  • SPINACH
  • ROASTED PEPPER
  • SAUSAGE
  • SPICY PEPPERONI
  • BBQ CHICKEN
  • BUFFALO CHICKEN
  • EGGPLANT
all prices are in $
SQUARES
background-img
SALADS & BREADS
SIDES
SALADS & BREADS
Price
  • GARLIC KNOTS 4
  • PEPPERONI WHEEL 5
  • CHEESE CALZONE 8.50
  • CHICKEN ROLL 8.50
  • CAESER SALAD 8.50
  • HOUSE SALAD 9.50
BEVERAGES
  • BOTTLED WATER 2.25
  • SMART WATER 3
  • BOTTLED SODA 3
  • MEXICAN SODA 3.50
  • GOLD PEAK ICE TEA 3.25
  • Vitamin Water 3.25
all prices are in $
* New York state sales tax not included.

Payment with credit or debit card will incur a non-cash adjustment fee of 3.95%. There is no fee applied for cash payments.
TOP ME UP!

Perhaps sooner than expected, pizza textbooks will tell tales of the fresh selection of toppings that hung out at 271 Amsterdam Avenue, too, like roasted peppers, mushrooms, onions, and then some. Is this that NYC pizza place where the phrase “extra spicy pepperoni and sausage, please” was used so often out of sheer deliciousness? Inside sources say yes (wink wink).

IN CRUST WE TRUST

Halfway between Riverside Park and Central Park lies this Upper West Side pizza joint that serves seriously satisfying slices and squares. Easy online ordering and delivery is the way we roll here, and take-out too; that’s if you manage not to gulp and munch it right on the spot. Hit up your gluten-free and vegan pizza-loving friends – we’re open from 11 am until late.