Pizza in the Upper West Side

One of the most sought-after food items on the Upper West Side is pizza.
But Made in New York Pizza stands out from the rest because of the sheer variety of delicious pizzas that you can get. From classic staples to some more unique toppings, you’ll be able to find it all on our menu.

Slices & Pies

  • plain cheese 3.25 | 22

    Crushed Tomato Sauce + Mozzarella

  • pepperoni 4.50 | 27

    Pecorino Romano, Mozzarella, + Pepperoni

  • bbq chicken 5.25 | 32
  • sausage jalapeno 5.25 | 32

    fresh mozzarella cheese, sausage + jalapenos

  • fresh mozzarella margherita 4.50 | 27
  • vodka pie 4.75 | 30

    vodka sauce, pecorino romano, fresh mozzarella

  • buffalo chicken 5.25 | 32

    buffalo chicken + mozzarella cheese

  • white spinach 5.25 | 32

    mozzarella, fresh ricotta, pecorino romano, chopped garlic, + extra virgin olive oil

vegan & gluten free

  • gluten-free personal pie 16+

    any round pie 16 + $2 per topping

  • SPICY PEPPERONI 4.75 | 32

    crushed red pepper, fresh mozzarella, + thick hand cut, spicy pepperoni

  • original grandma 4.50 | 28

    fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano, hand-crushed seasoned plum tomatoes, fresh chopped garlic, sicilian oregano, extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil

  • upside down 4.75 | 32

    fresh mozzarella, parmigiano cheese, sicilian oregano, + extra virgin olive oil

  • eggplant

    fresh mozzarella, sicilian oregano, parmigiano cheese, + fresh eggplant

  • veggie 4.75 | 32
  • classic sicilian 4.50 | 27
  • white 4.75 | 32
Extra Toppings
$1.50 PER SLICE | $6 PER PIE

Salads & Breads

  • garlic knots $4
  • cheese calzone $5
  • cheese calzone $8
  • chicken roll $8
  • caesar salad $8
  • house salad $9
Bottles $3.50
Bottles $3.50
Bottled Water $2.50

* New York State Sales Tax Not Included.
Payment with credit or debit card will incur a non-cash adjustment fee of 3.95%. There is no fee applied for cash payments.



If you don’t feel like coming to our pizza shop on the UWS, then you can always get your order delivered right to your home or hotel room. That way you get to enjoy our food wherever you desire!

Made in New York Pizza opened our doors in 2018 and has been a go-to destination for a great slice or a whole pie ever since. We’re here to fulfill all of your pizza needs, so contact our team today and we’ll get you one step closer to getting the savory satisfaction you’re looking for!


If you’re looking for the best pizza on the Upper West Side (UWS), look no further! The freshness of our ingredients blended with the herbs & seasonings we use make for a slice that is distinctly New York.

Our location is halfway between Riverside Park and Central Park, making it an easy walk from many popular destinations in our neighborhood. Locals and tourists alike flock to our pizzeria for the combination of our atmosphere and the taste of our authentic New York style pizza.